Lian-Li PC-K5WX case review

Came across a new case today from Lian-Li (noted maker of PC cases shaped like yachts, trains, desks, buildings, and marine life) – this one was under $130, which is surprisingly-far below their usual price range.

k5wx-002

I guess this is sort of like Mercedes making cheap FWD hatchbacks as well as S-Class limos – read on to find out if it’s worthy of the Lian-Li name.

A little bit of history

I came across Lian-Li in the mid-’90s when they were a maker of aluminium mobile racks (caddies for putting hard drives from the IDE ATA/33 era into CD ROM Bays). This rack below, for example, has a bit of the Mercedes-grill look about it.

126159358_lian-li-aluminum-mobile-rack-rh-600-scsi-15000-rpm-ebayLian-Li decided to give cases a try in the late ’90s, and pioneered the concept of making them out of folded and pressed aluminium, for weight-reduction and coolness reasons. The mobile rack business is long-gone now, but their cases remain as understated, sometimes-quirky, and high-end choices for people with plenty of $$ to throw at a PC.

However, as PCs globally declined in popularity in the last 5-6 years, Lian-Li decided to cater for the low-end buyers too, by making a cheap-end case range from steel and plastic, initially under another brand called “Lancool”. This brand didn’t appear set the world on fire, so they are now reverting to making them under the Lian-Li brand, and calling them “Ebonsteel”, to differentiate them from their all-aluminium case range.

Lian-Li also have some sense to their numbering scheme for the PC-K5WX – PC means it’s a case, K means it’s a steel case, 5 is a size class, W means it has a window, and X means it has a black interior.

Looks better when it’s alive

LL’s own product-shot above is pretty crappy – these cases really need to be pictured with all their glowy LED lights and bays occupied to make them pop – hence the standard ATX-size PC components housed in a PC-K5WX for the shot below.

 

P60819-104843

 

There’s two 12cm blue-LED fans in the front that shine nicely through the mesh, and also give it some underbody street-racer glow on the floor. These fans, plus the single rear black 12cm fan, have 3-pin motherboard-compatible plugs so you can control them from your motherboard. I’ve installed a DVD drive in the top, and a card-reader with USB and other IO ports in the bottom bay.

P60819-102732

This version of the PC-K5WX comes with a crystal-clear side-window – the non-window one is not imported to Australia. If your motherboard has LEDs on it, such as the Asus Maximus VIII Hero with it’s colour-changing heatsink LED, they’ll be visible.

You can just see the rubber feet on the bottom, which stand it off the ground by more than 2cm – this ensures that plenty of air will get drawn to the power-supply air-intake in the floor, which is also going to be a cat/dog hair magnet, so it’s good that they installed a removable filter there. The front is also a filter of sorts, and is smooth enough to let you just run a vacuum-cleaner brush across it to get all the cruft off.

P60819-102752

The rear of the PC-K5WX is pretty bog-standard for a PC case: thumbscrews for the doors and rubber pipe outlets for watercooling gear being indicators of it’s gamer-focused nature. The fan hole has a graduated set of screw holes to suit different sizes of fans or radiators. You could mount your power supply either way up, but it makes the most sense to mount it with it’s fan facing the floor to ensure cool intake air gets to it.

P60819-102815

The top has a bunch of useful ports for USB2, USB3 and HD audio – these all connect to your motherboard pinouts, so no looping to the back IO shield is required.

Drive bays – the good and the bad

There’s room for four disk drives in the front-bottom of the PC-K5WX – the good things about these are that the clip-in removable trays make for quick installation (no screws required), and you can drop 3.5inch drives into them without needing any retaining screws either. They even include rubber pads on the drive locating pins, so that drive motor whine is damped, very clever.

P60819-102905

Those four drive trays are housed in two cages – the cages are held in place by four screws each at the back, so if you need more than 25cm depth, eg for a ridiculously-long ePeen video card, you can move them about to create a space up to 40cm deep. There’s a manual at LL’s product page if you want to see how this is done.

All the drives installed here will be bathed in a steady flow of fresh intake air from the two low-RPM LED fans.

And, all four hard drive bays can accept the popular 2.5inch SSD drives with screws from underneath – no need to buy any brackets, as you do with older cases.

P60819-102918

The downside of all this convenience is that 3.5inch drives are not retained firmly enough to survive the PC being dropped off the back of a truck. If this happens to your PC, you’ll likely find the drives adrift when you open it. It’s probably best to put some foam in between these kinds of drives if you plan on entrusting a built PC to a courier journey across the country.

P60819-112136

The top two DVD bays have plastic clips to retain their drives, again avoiding screw-work, although you can use screws instead, as we did here. There’s an unimpeded airflow passage in a mostly-straight slightly-diagonal line from the top-front intake fan to the CPU cooling fan, so you can overclock a bit without worrying about airflow constrictions causing overheating issues.

Interior layout

Compared to much more expensive cases, the interior of the PC-K5WX is a little tight, but everything does fit standard ATX-size boards, just. The edges are all rolled smooth, and the entire thing is painted black. There are small hoops scattered around the motherboard/drive cages area for cable-ties to help secure cables.

P60819-102933

You can see the red and white SATA cables at the top-right are juuuuuust making the turn at the drive bays, and there is juuuuuuust room for the excess cable bundles from the PSU to live behind the drive cage. There’s room behind the motherboard to guide the power and data cables to the drives, though.

P60819-102947

Here in the top of the PC-K5WX, you can see the enormous mesh filter above the CPU cooler (up to 16cm-tall coolers will fit) – this is a pretty good way to ensure that the heat rising from any components gets out, and incidentally provides cats with a nice warm spot to snooze on. This area can take two additional 12cm fans, or a double-wide watercooling radiator, but you may have to relegate any DVD drive to the lower DVD bay to ensure there’s sufficient clearance for pipes.

Is it noisy?

Despite the fairly-open nature of the front and top mesh, this is a reasonably quiet case. The open-ness of the case structure means Lian-Li can get away with using low-RPM case fans, and as the power-supply’s intake fan faces the floor, it’s noise is also well muffled. If you pick an upright CPU cooler with a slow 12cm fan, such as the Deepcool S40 Gammaxx we used here, you won’t hear this PC in general use. Case design and fan selection has come a long way from the late ’90s, when most gamers wore headphones to muffle the jet-turbine howl of the 6cm cooling fan that recycled the hot air in the case through the CPU heatsink sideways, over and over:

1-Screenshot 2016-08-19 15.22.05

The mostly straight airflow pathway from the front-middle of the case to the CPU fan and then out via the rear fan means a reasonable flow of fresh outside air reaches the CPU heatsink and does not get recycled, so low-RPM fans can be used.

Is it worthwhile?

There’s plenty of competition in the case bottom end – $60-$100 cares abound, although the design and appearance of many is often garish or just plain ugly, and finger-cuts from the cheaper punched-steel ones will still be healing long after their cheaper prices are forgotten. The PC-K5WX sits towards the top-end of the pricing pack, so they do not appear to have tried to cruel the features in order to steal the bottom-price leaderboard. Quality is at least as good as Coolermaster, or Corsair, both makers of decent middle-range cases. You get the brand cachet of a decent case maker, but not the price, of their top-end offerings. Probably best for people who want something decent, and not too flashy, who want to house a gaming or workstation PC without ludicrous video cards.

  1. Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: